Boredom is a Boring Excuse- argumentum ad ignorantiam

Frequently you will notice a student in your class how is either bored or simply lazy. The definitions of these two words are different but the effects and symptoms are the same.  Some children are in fact truly bored  in school which in our NCLB driven world often happens to our  bright kids. Even in a perfect world of individually applied differentiation boredom would exist and that is a reality that our parents and students must accept. Many of us face at least some boredom issues  in our day-to-day lives as adults. To totally protect our children from boredom is to deny them a lesson in adult living.

It is nearly impossible in most cases to tell if  a child is  bored because they already know what you are teaching or because they refuse to participate in learning it.  Testing can sometimes gives us a clue to the answer to this  conundrum. But  I have seen more than one smart kid tank a test on purpose from lack of any desire or need to prove what they already know.  Beware of the apparently bright student who always gets exactly a 70%  ‘C” on tests, for they can do the math in their head even when  the test has 67 questions on it.

The student’s, ” I’m bored,” or the parent’s” he or she is bored,” is possibly now the most common of student and parent excuses/complaints.

First of all to understand this common complaint we,  like  Professor Harold Hill in the Music Man , ” gotta know the territory.” School, when compared to HDTV sports, action packed video games and phones that have more computing power than the antiquated computer on the teacher’s desk,  is going to suffer by the comparison.  The entertainment value of school , to paraphrase Lincoln, boring for some students all of the time and all of the students some of the time. Many students today are way too far down the  primrose path of  instant gratification and lack of any reasonable self-discipline habits. Many live in a world of  rapid fire positive reinforcement and  constant no penalty do-overs that was created not by them but by  the adults around them.  This is currently endemic in our society. It is difficult for some kids and parents   to understand that school must operate under a different set of rules than those found at home or  in video games. Things have changed from when the statement, ” I’m bored,”  resulted in a request to go mow the lawn with a push mower or clean the basement floor with a scrub brush instead of the current. ” let’s go buy you a new video game.” As Hamlet might say in response, “Aye There’s the rub.”

In too many cases when faced with the now ubiquitous ‘I’m bored,” plaint as a teacher I was never able to tell if  the students were  bored because they already had mastered everything or they were bored because they had never mastered anything. I would guess that it may be about 50/50 for the truly bored.

I have seen cases where boredom was a clear factor in lack of “measurable” student progress but in most  cases it was more of a “why should I have to do this when I don’t want to” problem rather than boredom.

I believe the genesis of the  boredom problem lies most often in the  home not in the school. Students too often learn the need to be entertained constantly and the avoidance of all responsibility for their own entertainment, while at the same time  failing  to learn the valuable lessons of creativity and  taking pride in accomplished work that introspection and self-reliance generate.  Most students have learned this lesson  long before teachers and schools have anything to do with it.

The boredom claim, like ignorance of the law as a defense against criminal behavior  is not a valid excuse for bad behavior or failure to work in school  because as Seldon told us,  “all may claim it and none may prove it.”


About safrisri

I was a school teacher until retirement. I have taught at all educational levels from pre-school to college. My college degree is general science which I arrived at after 5 years and 5 different majors. A degree as it turns out, almost as valuable and in demand as one in Neo-Bulgarian Mythology. I have been around education for around 40 years and can remember when teaching was a pleasant, happy and creative job and our schools were the same. Now I'm the guy sitting on the porch with an opinion on everything.
This entry was posted in education, Education Reform, teaching, Uncategorized and tagged , . Bookmark the permalink.

3 Responses to Boredom is a Boring Excuse- argumentum ad ignorantiam

  1. HaLin says:

    *I remember (the wonders of modern-day prediction softwares…)

  2. HaLin says:

    I remembering being bored straight away at subjects I had no obvious interest in. But in others that I particularly liked, I began enthusiastically but my body ‘tended to sway back in my seat’, so to speak, if the teacher lacked the ability to constantly stir my curiosity.

    • safrisri says:

      Nearly all kids come into schools with curiosity and imagination…. to often some teachers do their best to kill those natural instincts and replace them with compliance. Compliance is a necessary ingredient of education but by far not the most important one


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s